
The early 2000's can certainly be seen as the golden age of Omaha-based independent record label Saddle Creek, fostered on by the label's early hand in the emerging indie-folk/emo spectacle. Spurred on by Conor Oberst's Bright Eyes recordings and other similar acoustic waifs with warbling voices, Saddle Creek pressed the best of what was coming out of the American North and Midwest.
I remember walking into my hometown's one independent record store, stationed on the middle of Main Street, to buy a copy of “One Jug of Wine, Two Vessels” when it was released in 2004. Oberst had just released an ambitious dual-album, the dichotomous folk/electronic “I'm Wide Awake It's Morning/Digital Ash in a Digital Urn.”
Combined with 2002's “Lifted,” Bright Eyes had just finished a trio of highly acclaimed LP's. Combining with label-mates Neva Dinova, the two Omaha bands collaborated on a new six song EP, “One Jug of Wine, Two Vessels.”
Less of a traditional split and more of a mixed collaborative effort, “One Jug” featured a new band lineup fronted by Conor Oberst and Neva Dinova's Jake Bellows, along with members of other Saddle Creek notables such as Tilly and the Wall and Cursive.
Without much in the way of explanation, this rather overlooked EP was rereleased as a digital download in March, featuring four new tracks – two from each contributing band.
In a surprising move, Oberst has resurrected the Bright Eyes name for this project, after changing the name and configuration to his band to reflect his newfound artistic ambitions.
If the name is the same, the Conor Oberstof the rerelease is not the Conor Oberst of Bright Eyes' more bombastic days. The warbling and liquor-soaked “heart-on-sleeve” appeal is gone. The fact remains: Conor Oberst grew up, as did we, and in our wish for a nostalgic return to emo's golden days, he simply cannot provide in the same way he could five years ago.
The two Bright Eyes tracks on the EP are strong. “Happy Accident” stands on its merit as a mediocre pop-rock song. “I Know You” is far more on target, a poisonous song aimed at what could be an unfit, unwed mother. Decent as these songs may be, when placed next to original track “Black Comedy,” they come off as a somewhat hollow attempt at recapturing a fleeing feeling.
The two new Neva Dinova tracks on the rerelease are remarkably solid, considering the relative weakness of their 2008 LP “You May Already Be Dreaming.” The EP's introductory track, “Rollerskating,” is upbeat in a way that differs intensely from the usual barstool soliloquies penned by Bellows. “Someone's Love” treads on that more familiar territory, but does so in a way that outshines the material presented on “You May Already be Dreaming.”
The older, existing tracks on “One Jug” hold up well six-years after their initial release. Songs like “Poison” and “Spring Cleaning,” both crooned by Bellows with the latter being penned by Oberst, are undeniable highlights on the EP. Stepped in slide guitar reverb, Bellows is the voice of lonely night contemplation. Oberst's songs, “Black Comedy” and “I'll Be Your Friend” showcase the desperation and crooked social awkwardness that made the mid-career Bright Eyes albums so accessible and embracing.
Both Bellows and Oberst were some of the most innovative and skillful songwriters on Saddle Creek during the label's explosion in underground popularity, and while “One Jug” passed by without much notice, the split EP is an excellent testament to the early days of midwestern emo's successful flirtation with folk and alt-country.